Showing posts with label Patients. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Patients. Show all posts

Monday, December 31, 2012

When to believe my patient: Cynicism versus gullibility

During one of my medicine rotations this past year, I picked up a patient who had been admitted the previous night for abdominal pain. This was a middle-aged guy who had been in and out of the Emergency Department more than 7 times over the past few months for the same problem. A thorough chart review showed that he had the million-dollar work-up several times over, including half a dozen abdominal CT scans, and absolutely no biological cause was found to explain his symptoms.

Importantly, he also had a distant history of IV heroin abuse. On admission the night before, he said that he slipped up once a few months prior but swore he hadn't used since then. The admitting intern handed him off to me as a "drug-seeker with functional abdominal pain."

Talking briefly with my patient before rounds, I just didn't get the sense that he was drug-seeking. My resident was more cynical; he called me naive, but he also gave me leeway to do with my patient as I saw fit.

After rounds that morning, I spent a little more time with my patient. "What exactly happened a few months ago that caused you to use heroin again?" I discovered that his wife had committed a violent suicide and that he had found her. He blamed himself for her death. This was a revelation to me. Incredibly, my patient felt that he had put this traumatic event behind him, despite never going through any grieving process. He didn't draw any connection between his wife's suicide and his current abdominal pain, even though his pain began at around the same time.

I gently suggested to him that perhaps his abdominal pain was a result of that psychological trauma. He resisted that idea because, to him, it implied that he was "crazy" or making it up, and the pain felt so real to him. I asked him to just consider it and told him that I would return later in the afternoon to talk more.

During our next conversation later that afternoon, he was surprisingly receptive to the possibility of a psychogenic cause of his abdominal pain. "In all of my hospital visits, not a single doctor has suggested that, but it makes sense." He was in unbearable pain even then, so I suggested that we try a simple breathing relaxation technique. After five minutes of this, we got his pain down to a manageable level, and he seemed bolstered by the improvement. At this point, I was practically convinced that his abdominal pain was psychogenic in nature.

We were treating his abdominal pain with narcotics, which is a poor choice of medication because it can actually cause constipation and exacerbate abdominal pain. I suggested that, overnight, he first try the relaxation technique that I had taught him and only ask for oxycodone if he really needed it. This was the real test: How much pain medication would he ask for? When I came back the next morning, I found that he decreased his oxycodone from 10 mg every two hours to 5 mg every eight hours. This was objective evidence that my patient was not drug-seeking and supported a diagnosis of pain disorder.

My resident and attending were both surprised, to say the least. The management of drug-seeking patients is truly difficult, especially at a safety net hospital that predominantly serves a socioeconomically disadvantaged population with a high proportion of drug addicts. I grant that I am naive and perhaps too trusting when it comes to handling these patients. But I also see that if I hadn't at least been open to believing my patient's story, that he was in fact not drug-seeking, I would have failed to properly identify the underlying cause of this man's abdominal pain. This hospital visit would have been just as unproductive and wasteful as the previous 7 admissions. Most importantly, his abdominal pain would have persisted, with inappropriate medical treatment, and his need for counseling would have continued to go unrecognized.

Before discharging my patient, we started him on an antidepressant and gave him a list of psychiatrists who he could see on an outpatient basis. He had already made an appointment with an outpatient psychiatrist before leaving the hospital.

He was tearful when we said goodbye, thanking me for genuinely helping him after many frustrating hospital visits. Then he handed me a folded piece of paper, a letter addressed to my attending, who later shared it with me and quoted it verbatim in my evaluation:

I have been in and out of the hospital the last few months. No reasons were found for my problem until I was assigned Mr. O. He was able to help me in such a way that I am able to function again. He spent a good deal of time talking to me about my medical and personal life. He personally has brought back faith and recovery for me. He spent his personal time explaining ways to help with pain. I wanted to tell you that I am grateful for all his council, medical advice and help.

Friday, September 7, 2012

Answering personal questions from patients

I was interviewing a depressed patient with my attending in the room, watching. I asked my patient if she had any thoughts of death or dying, and she said yes. "Well what of it? Haven't you had those thoughts?" This direct personal question took me aback. I faltered, then I answered her question. I knew right away that she was trying to rationalize her own morbid thoughts by normalizing them. See, you think about death, too, so my thoughts of death are normal.

Then she turned to my attending and asked him the same question, but he handled it completely differently. He sat back relaxed in his chair, looked down at the floor briefly then right back up at the patient meeting her eyes, he smirked slightly, then he said, "You know, I think it's really interesting you asked me that." His voice was saturated with sincere curiosity. "Why is it do you think you asked me that?"

I was in awe. How deftly he had flipped her question right back to her and incorporated the very fact that she had asked that question into an exploration of her depressive symptoms! The patient went right along with the flow of the conversation. My attending never did end up answering her question.

I talked with my attending about it afterward. "You're going to be asked a lot of personal questions throughout your career: Are you single? Do you have children? How much money do you make? There's always something behind the question, and it's your job to figure out what it is." He went on to say that a very real power differential exists in the clinical interview. It's not unfair; that's just the way it is. If I ever feel like a patient is interviewing me, that should give me reason to pause and wonder, Why? From there, I should let my own curiosity guide my response.

This lesson made quite an impression on me, and it gave me an important tool to use in future clinical interviews.

Sunday, July 15, 2012

Zebra hunter

Working on a consult service is very different than taking care of my own patients. The primary care team calls up neurology when they think that a patient of theirs has neurological problems. The neurology team evaluates the patient, gives the primary team a set of recommendations, and follows the patient until the neurological issues are resolved.

Over the past two weeks, I have seen what a "good" consult looks like and what a "bad" consult looks like. A "good" consult has a true neurological problem with a clear question for the neurology team.

We had a "bad" consult the other day that was essentially, "I think my patient has corticobasilar degeneration," a neurodegenerative disorder similar to Parkinson's disease but much more rare. The resident who ordered the neurology consult anchored onto a very rare neurologic diagnosis and basically wanted the neurology team to confirm his diagnosis.

On exam the patient did indeed have some parkinsonian signs and symptoms, but he was also taking some medications that could potentially cause those symptoms.

My neurology resident got frustrated when he was pressed on corticobasilar degeneration. He finally told the primary care resident (in a very professional manner) that the neurology recommendations would be the same regardless of whether the true diagnosis ends up being corticobasilar degeneration, Parkinson's disease, or drug-induced parkinsonism: Discontinue all medications that could cause parkinsonian symptoms and re-evaluate the patient in two days.

This could have been a "good" consult if it was worded differently: "I have a patient with intention tremor, small handwriting, and cogwheel rigidity who is also taking psychotropic medications. Our team wants you to evaluate the patient to rule out Parkinson's disease or parkinsonian variants."

Aside from learning what good and bad consults sound like, I also learned that one quickly develops a reputation based on behavior like this. When my resident staffed this patient with the neurology attending, the attending interrupted to ask, "Is this the zebra hunter resident who ordered this consult?" His reputation had preceded him.

Sunday, May 27, 2012

Ethical ambiguity: When to certify a psychiatric patient

The greatest difficulty I've had during my psychiatry sub-internship is deciding when to take away someone's personal freedom by placing them on a mental health hold (MHH) or a short-term certification (STC). My attending told me at the beginning of the rotation, "I want you to make decisions about your patients. We'll do what you want, so long as you can explain why you're doing it and you have your head screwed on straight."

This responsibility hit home a few weeks ago when I knocked on my attending's office door to talk with him about a patient. I was uncertain about whether to place this patient on a STC. My attending sat back in his chair and listened while I explored both sides of the argument.

On the one hand...

This is a middle-aged guy with an unclear history of psychosis who's experiencing paranoid delusions to the extent that he has isolated himself from the entire world, including his family. He has a history of attempting suicide, and there is evidence of increasingly bizarre and disorganized thoughts. According to the police who originally placed him on a MHH, the patient's apartment was a disaster. Charcoal briquettes were placed around the periphery of each room, bed and couch and lamps were turned upside down, curtains were turned inside out, and two pennies were placed in strange places like in the refrigerator and in the shower. This is a man who could certainly benefit from continued hospitalization and treatment.

On the other hand...

The patient does not want to stay in the hospital, does not want treatment, and does not believe he has a mental illness. He shows no depressive symptoms and denies wanting to hurt himself or other people. He sure has some bizarre and paranoid thoughts, and doesn't have a job, but he pulls in a Social Security disability check each month and is able to clothe and feed himself. He may or may not meet legal criteria for being "gravely disabled," which would justify holding him on a STC.

When I finished, my attending leaned forward, looked at me intently, and asked, "So, what are you going to do?" I understood what he was doing: pushing me to make a tough decision and stick by it. This is part of my education, the process of becoming a doctor.

"I don't know, that's why I came to you for advice."

"Do you think this patient is mentally ill and needs treatment?"

"Yes."

"Do you believe that he is a danger to himself or others?"

"No."

"Do you believe that he is gravely disabled?"

"Possibly."

My attending then advised me to remember that my primary responsibility is to my patients. As long as I believe that I am following the law, I should do what I think is necessary to take proper care of my patients and let the judge decide if our actions should be upheld.

"So, what are you going to do?" my attending asked again, this time with an amused smirk.

"I'm going to cert him."

Although he never explicitly said so, it was clear to me that my attending thought that we should keep this patient on a STC.  I made the decision, though, based on my gut feeling that my patient was indeed gravely disabled and would benefit from treatment.

The patient stayed for another week with nominal improvement of his paranoia and disorganization. He agreed to keep taking medications after he left the hospital. That was something.

Everything about this patient's case was ambiguous to me. Did I really help him by keeping him in the hospital against his will? Was I justified in holding him on a STC? Was he really gravely disabled? Sometimes there are no clear answers, and I just have to make a decision that seems best at the time. I feel better knowing that I would make the same decision again if I had to do it over.

Monday, May 21, 2012

The legal side of psychiatry

Most of the inpatient psychiatry patients I have seen were admitted voluntarily. But some patients can be held involuntarily if they meet certain criteria: 1) They pose a threat to themselves, 2) They pose a threat to others, and 3) They have grave disability. Those first two are self-explanatory; "grave disability" just means that a patient's psychiatric illness impairs his or her ability to properly care for themselves. Think food, clothes, and shelter.

A mental health hold (MHH) is the shortest involuntary hold at 72 hours. Its purpose is to further evaluate a patient's mental state according to the above three criteria. There are important legal implications of the MHH. Most importantly, since the purpose of the MHH is fact-finding, the psychiatrist is allowed to obtain medical records from other institutions, and talk with the patient's friends and family, without the patient's consent. This means that if a patient is initially admitted on a MHH then switches to voluntary status, the psychiatrist is no longer able to get that information if the patient doesn't agree to it. I saw this happen a few times.

Short-term certification, which lasts for 3 months, is the next step of involuntary hospitalization. By the end of a 72 hour of a MHH, the psychiatrist must convince a judge that short-term certification is necessary, again demonstrating that the patient poses a threat to himself or others or has grave disability. Long-term certification lasts an additional 6 months and also has to be argued before a judge to be granted.

Lastly, there are involuntary medications (i-meds), which are exactly what they sound like. Typically, a patient flies out of control after refusing voluntary medications, emergency medications (e-meds) are given to control the patient in the short-term, then the case is brought before a judge to grant power to administer i-meds. Concern for the physical safety of fellow patients and staff is often cited as justification for requesting i-meds.

The gravity of depriving a person of freedom is not lost on me.

Going to court

One particularly memorable patient took his case to court. Among other problems, this patient had delusions of grandeur that led to increasingly serious run-ins with the law.

The patient was shackled and escorted to the courthouse by a sheriff, while the rest of us piled into a government-issued van for a field trip. The intern would be testifying, a first for him. He practiced his testimony on the ride over, and the attending prepared him for what to expect. "The public defender is going to try to discredit you as an expert witness. Don't worry: It's not personal, and the judge will likely rule in your favor."

That's exactly what happened. My intern became a newly-minted "expert" with the privilege of providing testimony related to the matter of placing our patient on a short-term certification. He stood at the podium with his hands clasped tightly behind him, so tightly in fact that his fingertips were white. His back was straight, his shoulders squared, his head held high, and in that pose he answered questions thoroughly but succinctly in a clear and certain voice. I was very impressed.

After some back-and-forth questioning from the public defender and city attorney, the patient/defendant had the opportunity to address the court. It turned out that our patient sealed his own fate with a diatribe that clearly demonstrated to the judge that he poses a threat to himself and suffers grave disability. We won short-term certification and the ability to administer involuntary medications.

Observing the legal process in action was fascinating, a valuable component of my psychiatry education.


Update: This patient is now doing fairly well. My intern writes:
The patient became less and less resistant to medications as he become more linear and logical. He never quite thanked us for forcing medication on him, but he did start saying positive things about the way he was thinking. Before he left, he actually became quite socially appropriate, responding to social cues, which previously he had not been able to do. He started telling jokes, some pretty funny and some bizarre. But he would occasionally follow a bizarre comment with reality testing saying, "Does that sound crazy?" and then laugh it off. At discharge, he was nervous to go home and thought it was happening too fast. Last I checked, he was making his outpatient appointments. His home visits have found him pleasant; he has been very welcoming to his case worker and showing off how clean and organized his apartment is, as well as new writings he has been working on.

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

From clinic to the operating room

A new patient was referred to the gynecology clinic from an outside community clinic that serves a low-income population. She was at the end of her rope dealing with symptoms from a condition that she allowed to progress for so long because she couldn't afford to fix it.

I was working with the chief resident, who is essentially almost a "real" doctor; even she was taken aback. "I'm going to go talk with the supervising doctor, and we'll see what we can do for you." The attending was equally impressed with the patient's history and physical exam and scheduled her for surgery the very next day.

My resident invited me to watch the surgery. "It'll give you a chance to follow a patient from start to finish." Thank you so much! This kind of continuity, as a medical student, is not the norm. I had to play hookie from afternoon clinic (with the chief's permission) in order to see my patient's surgery.

During the first two weeks of this clerkship, I saw many surgeries on women whom I had never met and never examined. The only history I knew of them is what I read in their chart and what the resident told me beforehand. Occasionally, I'd have a few minutes to chat with these patients immediately before surgery. But the whole experience felt disjointed.

That's why I'm incredibly grateful to have experienced the kind of continuity of care, from clinic to surgery, that the residents and attendings enjoy. The attending even stepped back allowing my resident to operate and leaving me to first-assist! And she invited me to accompany her to talk with the patient's family afterward! The experience felt complete.

I think more effort should be made to give medical students this kind of patient continuity. In terms of teaching and learning, I personally find that such continuity is especially effective: I will never forget this patient.

Saturday, March 10, 2012

Pushing back against the war on vaccines

It was bound to happen eventually on my pediatrics rotation: coming across parents who for one reason or another refuse to vaccinate their children.

The most recent anti-vaccination movement stems from a 1998 Lancet article that ostensibly showed a link between the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine and a so-called "bowel-brain syndrome" that involves non-specific bowel inflammation and a regressive type of autism. Vaccination opponents seized upon this article as legitimization of their views while the medical community collectively gasped.

Much has been written about the methodological and ethical problems with the study; a lot of time and energy was invested into reproducing or disproving the results of this study. Ultimately, though, it was an investigative journalist who showed that the author of MMR-autism study had allegedly cooked the data for financial gain (How the case against the MMR vaccine was fixed, British Medical Journal, 5 JAN 2011). This led to a formal investigation, public censure of the primary author, and the paper's retraction more than a decade after its publication.

But not before the damage was done. The authors of this paper used a respected and authoritative medical journal as a platform to spread what appear to be lies, the result of which was millions of parents questioning whether they should give their children the MMR vaccine - or any vaccine - for fear that it will cause autism. Many parents who had the misfortune of learning that their child has autism, desperately searching for reason, have stumbled upon the falsehoods spread by this article that seemingly explain the unexplainable.

Vaccinating children: Keeping the dialogue open

This is a dilemma faced by pediatricians worldwide, dealing with parents who are skeptical of vaccines or who flat-out refuse to vaccinate their children.

One such parent stood out over the course of my pediatrics rotation. She is the mother of an autistic child who hadn't received any vaccinations since 18 months and was coming in for a well-child visit. My preceptor warned me that this child's immunizations were not up to date and that the mother would likely continue to refuse all vaccinations. "What's your approach to such a parent?" I asked because some pediatricians (including one provider who I worked with previously) just have the parent sign a form without any discussion. "I always keep the patient in my practice, and I try to keep the dialogue open," she replied.

So, when it came time to talk about immunizations, I jumped right in:
"It seems that he's not up to date on his immunizations. Which shots do you want him to get today?"

Mom replied: "I don't want him to get any shots."

Feigned surprise: "Why not?"

"I just don't. He doesn't need them."

"Why do you think he doesn't need immunizations?"

"He just doesn't. He's not going to get sick."

My preceptor interjected: "Do you think there's a link between vaccinations and your son's autism? The only scientific publication that suggested a link was--"

"No, I don't believe that."

I sat back and thought for a few moments, perhaps slightly theatrically. "Tell me, what's your understanding of the diseases that these vaccinations protect against?" This question seemed to catch Mom off guard. The door was cracked slightly open, so I took the opportunity to educate Mom about hepatitis A and measles and mumps and rubella and chicken pox....

Oops, tactical error. Mom jumped on the chicken pox: "See, why does my son have to get a shot for chicken pox? I had it when I was a kid, and I did just fine!"

My preceptor rescued me: "Before we started vaccinating against chicken pox, a few hundred kids died from it every year. Percentage-wise, that might not sound like a lot, but if it's your kid who doesn't come home from the hospital because of chicken pox, then those chances are 100% for you. Did you have any complications from your chicken pox?"

"Yes, I was hospitalized for two days."

Then my preceptor closed the deal: "Well, it would be a horrible shame if your boy had to go through something like that if he didn't need to."

In the end, Mom agreed to vaccinate her boy against hepatitis A, influenza, and chicken pox, all that same day. She also agreed to vaccinate him against measles, mumps, and rubella, only if we could give those as separate shots.

Done!

I felt a real sense of accomplishment. Partially because of me, this little boy would now be protected against several serious diseases.

My opinion: Why every child should be vaccinated

Vaccines in general arguably represent the single most important development in medicine, ever. Some people may counter that antibiotics are a more significant advancement, and I'll give them that it would be a good debate.

But think for a moment: What would the world be like today if no vaccine had ever been developed? Just for starters, the world would still be ravaged by smallpox, a disease that few people can truly appreciate how devastating it really was. To put this in perspective, the Wikipedia page refers to smallpox in the past tense, citing its eradication in 1979! Then there's polio, which is so very close to also being referred to in the past tense thanks to a coordinated worldwide campaign to eradicate polio. Warehouses full of people living inside iron lungs are a nightmare of the past; we will never again have a President of the United States confined to a wheelchair because of polio.

Measles (one of the M's in MMR) is a great example of a horrific disease that practically disappeared because of population-wide vaccination but has recently made a resurgence, partly owing to the people who were never vaccinated against it. Measles is an incredibly infectious disease, which means that it's very easy to spread from one person to another. That in turn means that eradicating it will be that much more difficult, especially if there are significant pockets of the population who are susceptible to it. Recently, PBS reported on a mini-outbreak of 13 measles cases after the 2012 Super Bowl; all 13 cases had opted out of the MMR vaccine. In developed countries, one person will die of measles for every 1000 people who get the disease; mortality jumps to 5-10% for measles infections in developing countries (PLoS Med. 2007 January; 4(1): e24). Those are odds I wouldn't want to play around with.

The logic is simple: If you're vaccinated against Disease X, then you will not get Disease X. Given that the consequences of getting many of these preventable diseases include permanent disability, or worse, death, it's hard for me to understand why loving parents would would choose to not vaccinate their child.

Thursday, February 16, 2012

Abdominal pain in a child

Of all kids coming to the emergency department complaining of abdominal pain, plain old constipation is to blame 70% of the time. Just such a kid came into the ED, but it turned out to be much more interesting than constipation.

Talking to Mom, I found out that the girl had been having stomach pains intermittently for over a year, that she could be fine one minute but doubled up in pain the next. These episodes came in clusters, were not associated with school, and were separated by months with the last episode happening several weeks ago. She was indeed previously worked up extensively for her abdominal pain ruling out things like appendicitis, pancreatitis, and celiac disease. In fact, an abdominal x-ray a few weeks ago even ruled out constipation.


The little girl last had a bowel movement earlier in the day, and Mom noted it to be soft without excessive straining required to defecate. She also had two bowel movements the previous day. None of this was pointing toward constipation as the cause of this girl's abdominal pain.

My patient was difficult to talk to. She would hardly look at me. Even when I asked her simple questions like "What's your favorite color?" she would look over to Mom, who professed that her daughter was normally very talkative. Mom was also difficult to talk to: she couldn't get words out of her mouth fast enough, she went off on tangents before eventually answering my questions, and she spent a lot of time unloading all her worries about what might be causing her daughter's abdominal pain.

Within a few minutes of entering the room, and without even touching my patient on exam, I was already pretty confident about my diagnosis. This could be delicate and require some tact.

"Are there any significant psychiatric problems in the family?"

Jackpot. Mom described symptoms in herself highly suggestive of no less than three psychiatric diagnoses, all of them undiagnosed and untreated. She also said that the kid's father is on medications for two psychiatric disorders. Further delving into the social history revealed significant turmoil at home, including an absent father and other significant stressors.

After a thorough exam, I explained to Mom that I ruled out the scary stuff that could be causing her kid's tummy pain. I said that the clinical picture doesn't really fit a physical cause and that I thought it was more likely that her daughter's stress or anxiety might be behind her symptoms.

Brace for impact....

But to my surprise, Mom accepted what I had to say: "You know, that makes so much sense. No one has ever suggested that before!" Encouraged, I then explained to her that it is very common for children to convert emotional or psychological stress into physical symptoms and that this is called conversion disorder.

In hindsight, this child in fact didn't have conversion disorder because the diagnostic criteria for conversion disorder require another non-pain neurologic symptom, which this girl did not have. She probably met diagnostic criteria for chronic pain disorder with psychological factors, the treatment of which is psychotherapy and antidepressants.

I explained to Mom that it is really important that her daughter receive prompt treatment for this problem to decrease the chances of her developing other psychiatric problems such as an anxiety disorder. For what it's worth, she said she would follow up with her daughter's primary care physician for a referral to a child psychiatrist. I really hope that actually happens.

Sunday, February 5, 2012

Endless ear exams

My least favorite part of the physical exam is looking in ears. It's especially difficult in kids because their ear canals are small and crooked, and of course kids tend to squirm and scream when you try to stick something in their ear. Go figure. But a good ear exam is absolutely essential in pediatrics. That's why I made a point to hammer away at the ear exam until I got the hang of it.


Tough going, at first. Too often I would look in a kid's ears and just see a ball of wax, or the sides of the ear canals but no tympanic membrane. When ear pain wasn't a chief complaint and I wasn't concerned about an ear infection, I just nodded my head reassuringly and continued with my exam. This falls under the category of "Fake it until you make it" - first to avoid alarming parents that they are entrusting the care of their child to such an amateur, and second to protect my own ego. But I would return to my attending, tail between my legs, and sheepishly report "Tympanic membrane not visualized" in the physical exam section of my oral presentation.

The attendings are for the most part understanding that a third year medical student isn't going to do a first-rate ear exam. In fact, they seem to expect it. One attending said, "I don't even expect pediatric interns to give a good ear exam. You have to look at thousands of ears to get good at it." Fair enough. Being that we're in the middle of flu season, I've gotten a good jump-start on those thousands.

I think I'm already getting better. I'm probably visualizing about two-thirds of all the ears I look in, at this point, up from around 0-5%. If there's wax, I remove it and try again. If the kid is squirming, I coach the parent on how to hold the kid down. If the kid is screaming, I ignore it. I'm such a meanie.

But being a heartless sadist has paid off. Today a kid came in tugging at her right ear. I looked in the left ear first, then the right, and thought I saw infection in both. The left ear actually looked much worse with erythema in the canal, no light reflex, and yellowish fluid behind the tympanic membrane obscuring the bony landmarks. I described these details to my attending, aware that they were at odds with the patient's history. After doing her own exam, she said five words that every medical student loves to hear from their attending: "I agree with your findings."

Friday, February 3, 2012

Suturing on children

I feel pretty comfortable at this point suturing a superficial laceration. I've even sutured some lacerations in sensitive areas such as the face and hands. But, man, it's a completely different beast suturing on a screaming squirming child! I didn't try this, thankfully, but I saw several of them during my first week on pediatrics. With one kid, even a hit of Versed wasn't enough to calm him down!

One attending's advice: Immobilization. If you keep them completely immobile, they'll eventually stop trying to move; but if you let them move just a little bit, they'll squirm throughout the entire procedure. Just holding down their arms isn't enough. We used blankets to wrap these kids into burritos to immobilize their arms, legs, and torso all at once.

Another attending's advice: Patience. Make any sensitive movements while the kid is actually crying since they tend to be more still during exhalation. One attending spent what felt like 5 minutes trying to take out a single suture, his hand braced against the child's face steadying the scissors to be ready to snip the suture during the briefest window of calm.

To do a good job suturing on children takes a level of patience and steely nerves that I certainly admire.

Friday, January 27, 2012

Recidivism in psychiatric patients

It has been a running joke with one of my residents, my optimism when it comes to the chances that my patients will actually make meaningful changes in their lives. Out of curiosity, and as a sort of exercise, we sat down together and reviewed the charts of my patients from earlier in the month. My meth addict patient? Missed his follow-up appointments. My alcoholic patients? They all missed their appointments. My borderline patient with anger issues and family problems? "Oh, look," my resident chuckled, "He made his optometry appointment but missed his psychiatrist and family therapy appointments! That's interesting..."

She wasn't so much rubbing it in my face as making her point that, as a psychiatrist, you can't expect your patients to change any more than they are ready to change. It's easy to get discouraged and jaded, she said, the more of yourself you invest in their recovery. Her eyes widened for a flash, a microexpression. I think she got worried that I might judge her as jaded and cynical. But I understood what she meant. It was natural for me to want to single-handedly fix my patients' self-destructive behaviors, but the game was already lost the moment my motivation exceeded my patients' motivation for change.

Tuesday, January 10, 2012

Stepping into a teaching role

The other day I was working with my preceptor at the University emergency department when a maroon-vested undergraduate volunteer took to following me around. I happily answered several of his questions then referred him to this blog.

Later that evening, we were both watching a resident sew up a laceration. Even though the resident had already taken the patient's history, I asked the patient simple questions like how and when, as much for my own curiosity as for distracting her from the discomfort.

As I stood there watching the resident put in one simple interrupted stitch and then another, I realized that this kid standing next to me had little or no context and probably had absolutely no idea what was going on. So I decided to teach.

"The reason why I asked how it happened is because it could give me a clue as to how dirty that wound is and what possible organisms could be in there."

"I asked her when it happened because we don't typically close wounds on the extremities if they happened more than 8 hours ago. It could cause an anaerobic bacterial infection."

These are things that I take for granted now but that he likely didn't know.

The resident heard me teaching the volunteer and asked me if I wanted to finish up. Sure! As I put in the last three sutures, I verbalized everything: grip the needle in the middle of the curve using the tip of the needle drivers for better control, needle perpendicular to the skin, roll my wrist because the needle is curved, take an even bite on either side of the wound, don't tie the knot too tightly to avoid strangulating the skin, etc...

It felt good to be on the other end of information exchange for once. Teaching felt natural.

Sunday, January 8, 2012

Electroconvulsive therapy

I was introduced to electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) on just the second day of my psychiatry rotation. ECT was first developed in 1938. Although no one really knows how it works, the idea is that by inducing a controlled tonic-clonic seizure with electrical current, we can "reset" the brain's pathological function, whether that's by interrupting connections between different brain regions or altering the balance of neurotransmitters. It's a lot of hand-waving.

Regardless, ECT works; in fact, it works much better than any pharmacotherapy, including selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), with a 95% effectiveness. When used in depression, ECT has a recurrence rate of 50%, which is comparable to SSRIs. 100,000 people in the U.S. and 1,000,000 worldwide undergo ECT yearly, mostly for depression with psychotic features but also for schizophrenia; my attending thinks that ECT is underused.

With that background, I met my patient: an older veteran suffering from such severe recurrent depression with psychotic features that it led him to attempt suicide. He had already undergone four ECT sessions. On the morning of his fifth session, he was so nervous that he was visibly shaking. A friend held both of his hands and prayed briefly with him before we led the veteran through two locked doors and into the elevators down to the minor procedure suite. He walked bravely, as calmly as he could manage, because he knew that this treatment was necessary.

Image taken from the blog of actress Carrie Fischer, who has shared her experiences with ECT for bipolar disorder. (http://carriefisher.com)

Once he was lying on the procedure table, we placed blood pressure cuffs around both his ankles and inflated them so they would act as tourniquets to block the drugs from reaching his feet. The anesthesiologist sedated him, paralyzed him, placed a tongue guard in his mouth, and began breathing for him with a bag valve mask. Then, my attending poured gel onto two 1.5-inch diameter metal plates and secured those plates on the patient's temples with a rubber strap. The metal plates were connected to the machine that delivers a prescribed electric shock. A baseline electroencephalogram (EEG) was obtained, then the shock was delivered by simply pushing a button.

Suddenly, his toes curled and the arches of his feet flexed continually for the duration of the 8-second stimulus. I looked up at his face and was surprised to see a contorted grimace: clenched jaw and eyes shut tight. A few seconds after the stimulus ended, his feet began contracting and relaxing indicating that he was in the middle of the tonic-clonic seizure that is the goal of ECT. The foot twitching lasted about 20 seconds. The spike-wave squiggly lines coming out of the electroencephalography machine, indicating a seizure, flattened to baseline after 50 seconds indicating that the central seizure had stopped. Then the anesthesiologist woke him up. It was over.

From start to finish, the whole thing took less than a half-hour. This patient's ECT bore no resemblance to the dramatic convulsions and screaming that most people associate with ECT, thanks to Jack Nicholson's unnerving performance in One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest.



The addition of anesthesia to ECT protocol in the late 1960's (notably before this movie was released in 1975) has made ECT a much more humane experience. Paralytic drugs prevent the thrashing around, and some anesthetic agents can cause retrograde memory loss so the patient doesn't even remember the procedure. ECT itself can also cause retrograde memory loss as a side effect.

My patient remembered the anxiety leading up to his ECT treatment but not much else about it. We interviewed him briefly a few hours after his ECT session, and I was shocked (pun intended) by the transformation. He was freshly showered and was wearing a freshly ironed shirt that his friend brought from home; he was much more expressive and interactive, he wasn't hearing voices, he didn't have suicidal thoughts, and he said that he was actually feeling good. Despite the dramatic nature of ECT and its negative portrayal in the arts and media, it's hard to ignore such striking success.

Wednesday, January 4, 2012

Introduction to my psychiatry work environment

I am doing my psychiatry rotation at the Denver VA Medical Center, which has a 36-bed inpatient psychiatry unit. The psychiatry patients are cared for by three separate teams, two of which take medical students. My team is composed of one attending psychiatrist, two psychiatry residents, and one classmate.

The psychiatry ward is locked down, as one might imagine. You have to pass through two locked doors and walk by a security station to get into and out of the psychiatry ward. Plus, the security badges that unlock the doors only do so for a quick half-second before locking again, making escape by someone unfamiliar with this timing that much more difficult.

Once on the floor, there's a ten-foot stretch of hallway before reaching a taped red line on the white linoleum. Patients aren't allowed to walk beyond that line unchaperoned. Similar red lines are in front of doorways and serve to keep patients out of restricted areas. It's remarkable how well the red line works and how rule-driven these veterans are, in general.

Everything is designed so that it can't be used as a weapon. Drinking fountains have no spigot head, sinks have no faucet, chairs have no legs and are so heavy that they can't be picked but instead have to be scooted around the room. Doorknobs are not knobs, rather semicircles practically flush with the door with indentations for grips.

A wide array of patients stared at my attending, two classmates, and me as we walked down the hallway during our orientation. Some were poorly groomed; others were clean-cut. Some were wearing government-issued pajamas, a bath robe, and hospital socks; others wore street clothes and were actually sharply dressed for the setting.

An unfamiliar face in the psychiatry ward is the object of curiosity. Several patients stared at us three medical students with an unsettling vacant gaze that all of them seemed to share. One "happily demented" veteran, hunched over and pushing a walker, a smile on his face, approached us just to strike up a friendly conversation.

Another veteran, younger, balder, and unhealthily skinny, sidled behind the group and when he was noticed blurted out in one breath, "What do you know about perpetual consciousness? It's like a circle running around and around and around in your mind not stopping, which is ironic because," and he moved his finger in a circle by his head, then whispered, "it makes you look crazy." I felt uncomfortable. How do you respond to something like that? My classmates felt equally awkward. One of them decided to reply in the only way he knew how: "Hi, my name is John," offering a handshake.

This interaction made me understand that my biggest challenge for the upcoming psychiatry rotation will be to set aside my feelings of discomfort, and other negative emotions elicited by my patients' unusual affect and behavior, to make sure that they don't get in the way of my ability to understand and empathize with my patients. Easier said than done.

Monday, December 12, 2011

Backup plans

A patient was brought back to the OR for an emergency exploratory laparotomy one night while I was on call. I didn't scrub in on the case but instead hung out at the head of the bed with the anesthesiologist. Soon after he intbuated this patient, it became apparent that everything was not going according to plan. Oxygen saturation was dropping to the mid-80's indicating that the patient was not being ventilated properly.

The anesthesiologist quickly confirmed correct placement of the endotracheal tube then determined that the problem was with the ventilation machine itself. There was a leak. "Let's bag him," the anesthesiologist called out (referring to bag-valve mask ventilation). Ordinarily, the Ambu bag is kept in the back of the mechanical ventilator cart, but no Ambu bag could be found.


In this moment, I saw an "oh sh*t" look of panic in the anesthesiologist's eyes. Pointing to a nurse: "Go get me an Ambu bag from another room." Meanwhile, he started troubleshooting the leak in the ventilator machine. He found the faulty valve and fixed it in about 30 second to a minute, before the nurse came back with the Ambu bag, and stabilized the patient who by that time had oxygen saturation in the high 60's.

The surgeon quietly watched this all unfold, letting the anesthesiologist do his job without interfering. "I thought I was going to have to do mouth-to-tube ventilation," the surgeon joked after the patient was stabilized. I chuckled. After the excitement passed, though, I realized that the surgeon had probably actually considered the possibility of ventilating his patient by breathing into the endotracheal tube.

This gave me a lot to think about.

Narrowly, this experience has taught me that I should always have an Ambu bag at my fingertips before intubating a patient. More broadly, every anesthesiologist who I worked with has emphasized the necessity of having backup plans. Know what you're going to do to stabilize a patient if something goes wrong. Have a backup-backup plan if your first backup plan fails. It's one thing to hear it, but that lesson takes on a much greater significance seeing it unfold before my eyes.

Saturday, September 10, 2011

Jedi mind tricks

If you work at The Children's Hospital in August or September, back-to-school season, you're almost guaranteed to come across conversion disorder. This is the subconscious “conversion” of psychological stress into physical symptoms and can often be metaphorical. Conversion disorder is a diagnosis of exclusion, which basically means that you have to assume the worst and order a bunch of expensive tests to rule out all the bad stuff. While needlessly spending lots of money is never a good thing, it starts to get serious when we talk about invasive procedures, such as lumbar puncture, that carry a real risk of complication.

The phrase of the week was "Jedi mind tricks." My attending is a Jedi Master.

One kid presented with altered sensation. With his eyes closed, he tells the doctor that he doesn't feel the light touch of a cotton swab. Next, still with his eyes closed, the instructions are, "Tell me if you don't feel anything." Sure enough, he said that he didn't feel anything each time he was touched by the cotton swab. Unprompted. He's a precocious little bugger but not good enough to outsmart the Jedi Master!

Another kid presented with seizure-like episodes that were suspicious for not being true seizures, so-called pseudopesizures. When she was told that she wouldn't be able to eat dinner until her seizures stopped, her seizures suddenly stopped. Go figure.

My attending emphasized that conversion disorder is a subconscious maladaptive response to stress, a distinction that merits consideration when discussing the diagnosis. Patients will understandably get upset if the doctor implies that they are faking it. My attending has a standard script to open this conversation:
"People do funny things when they are under a lot of stress. Some people bite their fingernails, some people pull at their hair, some people pick their nose, and some people do what you're doing. I believe you that you're not making this up. That's why it's so important to figure out exactly what's going on with you. What kind of stress do you have in your life?

He also says that neurology is a glass-half-full specialty when it comes to such patients. "Give them the benefit of the doubt. Leave it to the psychiatrists to figure out whether it's conversion or factitious."

Sunday, August 21, 2011

Breaking bad news

One of my patients came in to the hospital for gastritis but ended up staying for a couple weeks because we discovered that she had acute worsening of chronic kidney disease secondary to diabetes and hypertension. Dahlia didn't seem to understand that out-of-control diabetes and hypertension directly caused her kidney injury. Up until this point, she had been asymptomatic. When sick people don't feel sick, and they lack education to understand the illness and money to buy medications, they tend to not take care of themselves properly.

"I know that you came here for your stomach problems, but the reason you're still here is because we found out that your kidneys aren't working well. We think you've been feeling nauseous because of your kidneys, not because of your stomach."

"Okay, doctor, what does that mean?"

"It means that we want to keep you here for a few more days to make sure your kidneys start working better and to get your blood pressure and diabetes under better control."

"Oh, okay doctor. Whatever you say I need to do to get better."

After a few more days with steadily climbing creatinine and continued worsening of kidney function, it became clear that Dahlia was going to need dialysis. If she was lucky, we'd be able to place a fistula for scheduled dialysis rather than start dialysis emergently.

Regardless, I took responsibility for talking to Dahlia about her worsening kidney disease and the need for dialysis. I dreaded the conversation. Like a good medical student, I printed out materials and prepared a pretty little speech to teach my patient about chronic kidney disease and dialysis. She only had one question for me when I finished: "Am I going to die?"

This question nearly knocked me to the ground. I wish that I could say that I provided a thoughtful and reassuring answer. But I didn't. Afterward, I went to my intern to see if he had any advice about how to handle this situation. "Ooooh, I can't believe you pulled the I-don't-have-a-crystal-ball line!"

I felt ashamed, even though implicit in his poking fun of me was the admission that once upon a time he too had fallen back on the crystal ball line. I wanted to be a doctor to my patient, not a medical student, an admittedly impractical aspiration given my inexperience in breaking bad news to patients.

This conversation continued over the next couple of days as her creatinine continued to creep upward, my patient languishing in the stench of her hospital-acquired depression. Each night on my way home from the hospital, I asked myself why I couldn't bring myself to tell my patient the truth. It didn't matter: I just had to tell her.

Brenner and Rector's The Kidney, 8th ed. Figure 17-9. Adjusted 5-year survival of U.S. incident dialysis patients by modality and primary diagnosis. (From U.S. Renal Data System: USRDS 2005 Annual Data Report: Atlas of End-Stage Renal Disease in the United States. Bethesda, MD, National Institutes of Health, National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, 2005, p 131.)

"The graph on the left shows you what your chances are of being alive five years after starting dialysis. You have an 80% chance of being alive at 1 year, a 60% chance of being alive at 2 years, a 40% chance of being alive after 3 years, and a 20% of being alive after 5 years. That means that for every five patients with diabetes starting dialysis, only one will be alive in 5 years. The outlook is a little better for people with kidney disease but who don't have diabetes; that's why we've been so concerned about controlling your blood sugar. Keeping both your blood sugar and blood pressure under control is the best way to keep you healthy and slow the progression of your kidney disease."

Dahlia's eyes drifted downward then darted upward and rightward and leftward then settled on the picture-perfect 9th floor cityscape that seemed to represent escape from this prison of disease and death. Her eyes looked everywhere except at me.

I finally realized that I had been afraid of burdening my patient with the knowledge of how she was going to die, and when, as if I could somehow protect her with a shroud of ignorance. How small and selfish I had been.

I looked out at the cityscape where Dahlia was still gazing with blank eyes.

"I want to go home."

Friday, July 22, 2011

Realities of working at a safety-net hospital

One of the patients I'm following managed to put together quite the interdisciplinary team. We consulted: infectious disease, GI, neuro, psychiatry, nutrition, speech therapy, social work, physical therapy, and occupational therapy.

Despite so many people and so many resources devoted to this patient, she still insisted on returning to the poor lifestyle decisions that landed her in the hospital in the first place. She understood how her actions negatively impacted her health and that she would likely wind up back in the hospital with the same problems, or worse. "Why change now?" I had a dozen answers to that question, but none of them mattered. She didn't want to die, yet she also seemed to accept early death as a consequence of living the rest of her life on her own terms.

I think what I'm feeling now is the prodrome of disenchantment.

Friday, July 15, 2011

Loose ends

I left loose ends at PSL.

The most important loose end is a patient who we admitted quite awhile ago. This patient has a rare disease with a very poor prognosis, and there were several times over the past month when we thought that he might pass away. I have observed with great interest the dynamics between the medical team and my patient's family and how those dynamics have impacted his process of dying.

I care very much for this patient. The last time I saw him awake, I held his hand to comfort him. There really wasn't anything else I could do to help. He looked up at me and whispered "Thank you." I could barely hear his words over the noise of the breathing machine and the mask over his mouth. The meaning was in his eyes. A single tear rolled down his cheek, and I caught it with my finger.

Then I squeezed his hand one last time and left. It was so much more difficult for me to leave him than to hold his hand.

Thursday, July 14, 2011

Preparing for the Hereafter

My resident came to me with a new patient who he wanted me to follow: “This is an elderly lady complaining of dizziness and fatigue [details changed]. On a scale of 1 to cute, she’s cute.” He was right. I immediately made a connection with Alice [pseudonym]. Even through her pain and discomfort, she was always pleasant and smiling and quietly encouraging me as a student of medicine in her gentle Southern twang. An aura surrounded her that she had experienced a lot of life and had perhaps learned some of its secrets.

When it came time to discharge Alice, I was selfishly sad that I would no longer have the pleasure of her company. That was when I decided that I would ask her if I could visit her in her home as part of a required assignment for this clerkship.

The point of this assignment is to emphasize the human component of the patients we see. My perception of my patients is very much colored by the only environment in which we have interacted, the hospital. I may have had some enjoyable conversations with Alice, and I may have met some of her family and friends, but my perspective of her throughout her hospitalization was necessarily one-dimensional.

What is her home environment like? I knew that her son was taking care of her, but what is the exact nature of that relationship? How does she manage her medications? How does she get around the house? What does she do for fun?

Alice and her son welcomed me into their home. It’s a small house located on a busy street, and it’s equally busy inside bursting with plants and pictures. Alice was in the living room when I arrived; I watched her get out of her chair and make her way to her motorized wheelchair 10 feet away, assisted by her walker. The whole process took about 2 minutes.

Alice explained that she likes to move about by herself, but her son is usually nearby to help her if she needs it. She further explained that her son does all the chores around the house, including managing her medications and preparing food. I noted the dozen or so medicine bottles perched on a tray built into her walker and the smell of an early dinner coming from the kitchen, where her son was humming and cooking away.

I asked her about her hobbies and what she does to keep herself busy. Without trying to hide her disappointment, she described how she had previously been very active in her church community but is now unable to get out and socialize. She doesn’t leave her house much at all. Even getting to her doctor’s appointments is a big deal.

Then she voiced her biggest concern: “My son is getting tired. It’s a big job taking of caring of me. I don’t know when I’m going to have to move into a nursing home.” I realized that this issue must weigh heavily on her mind. I didn’t have any easy answers for her.

We spent the rest of our visit together looking at pictures on the walls and talking about the people from her past who she has loved. Then it was time to leave.

“Goodbye, Alice. Thank you for your hospitality.”

“There ain't no goodbyes, honey. I’ll see you in the Hereafter.”