Showing posts with label Thoughts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Thoughts. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 1, 2013

Reality check

It's now 2013, my graduation year. I will be a doctor (technically) in 144 days. Crazy.

Monday, September 24, 2012

Well-deserved vacation

I finished the Davis externship, and now I'm on my first real vacation since Winter break in December 2011. The two weeks I spent at home last month don't count because I was studying for Step 2. So here I am back at home: nothing to study, no patients to care for, no responsibilities except to relax. It feels great.

Friday, September 21, 2012

Davis: End of the externship

My externship with the Davis combined medicine/psychiatry program ended today. I left the clinic this afternoon with a sense of satisfaction that the experience was all-around positive and that I received encouraging feedback from everyone. I'm sad to be leaving, and I'm eager to return to Davis for the interview; this speaks volumes about my gut-level feeling about the program.

I had two goals when I started this externship. First, I wanted to figure out whether combined medicine/psychiatry is right for me, or whether I might be better served by a pure medicine or pure psychiatry program. Second, I wanted to get a better feel for the UC Davis program, in particular: the leadership, the residents, the strength of the training, and the general environment of Sacramento.

On the first goal:

I am much more certain now than when I started this rotation that I want combined training. I could only feel comfortable coming to this conclusion after gaining first-hand experience in an environment that combines medicine and psychiatry to provide integrated patient care. This rotation leaned heavily toward the psychiatry end of the spectrum, much to my initial disappointment. But this limitation to my experience here at UC Davis provided a contrast that helped me appreciate the satisfaction I feel from treating patients' medical and psychiatric needs together.

Over these past four weeks, I learned why much of my clinic experience was straight psychiatry: MediCal reimbursement rules prevent billing for medical and psychiatric services in one visit. In fact, one of my last patients of this rotation lamented that she would soon have to find a new primary care provider for her medical needs because her insurance was switching over to MediCal. This is a woman with COPD, congestive heart failure, diabetes, and bipolar disorder, all of which my dually-trained attending has been managing well. She would be ill-served being forced to find a new primary care provider who just treats her medical needs. My attending says that changes to MediCal reimbursement rules are in the works to address this problem. This is a poignant lesson, though, of the types of struggles that I will likely face in choosing the combined medicine/psychiatry path.

On the second goal:

Over and over again, I was struck by how friendly and happy people are here at UC Davis. I'm left with the feeling that I would enjoy working with these residents and attendings, an extremely important feeling considering that these would be my colleagues for the next five years. Both the medicine and psychiatry programs, as well as the combined training program, are very strong. And Sacramento itself was a pleasant surprise. It's a small city with not too much going on, which suits my purposes just fine for residency. The heat was not unbearable as I was expecting. And it's close by to many attractions (e.g. San Francisco, Lake Tahoe, the Redwoods). My attending says that Sacramento is a better place to live than visit. I agree.



So, with everything said and done, my mind wanders back to about four years ago when I was visiting different medical schools. I remember walking around Colorado's medical school campus, taking everything in, thinking, "I could see myself happy here." And it turns out that I was. I get that same feeling from Davis. This is a nice starting point to have heading into interview season.

Saturday, September 15, 2012

Residency application: Submitted!

Today is a big day for fourth-year medical students all over the country, the day when we can finally apply for residency programs. This is done through ERAS, the Electronic Residency Application System that aggregates all application materials. The whole process is much simpler than applying for medical school. There are only three parts to ERAS that medical students have any control over: 1) the personal statement, 2) the curriculum vitae, and 3) letters of recommendation.

I did my fair share of freaking out about the personal statement. My perfectionist traits shine brightly when writing an essay that's meant to convey most of who I am and the kind of doctor I want to become, all in less than a page. But beyond that, I've had a surprisingly zen attitude about this new round of applications. It doesn't do to obsess about something that can't be changed. For all the nit-picking over my application this last week, the substance of my application has been settled for quite some time.

Perhaps that's why clicking the "Submit" button this afternoon felt anticlimactic. I celebrated, regardless. How exciting to think about all those program directors out there reading through my application! Nerve-wracking to wait for the interview offers? Yes. But I'm confident in my application and am looking forward to this next step in the long slog of becoming a doctor.

Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Be a sponge

I had lunch with the med/psych program director for my midpoint evaluation. His feedback was different than any of the feedback I have gotten during other midpoint evaluations, which more often than not are formalities and not all that helpful. "I want you to take a step back," he said. "I want you to absorb everything that's going on around you. Be a sponge."

This advice was especially interesting to me because it echoes something that a close friend told me as I headed off to medical school: "Be a medical anthropologist. Look at what works and what doesn't work in the medical system and think about how you would do it differently." So, throughout medical school, I have been purposefully doing just that. Here at UC Davis, taking a step back and observing as much as possible of my surroundings and the people around me, that is all the more important as I am trying to figure out whether this is the right residency program for me.

Wednesday, August 29, 2012

Studying for Step 2: A thank-you to my parents

I want to say a special thank you to Mom and Dad.

Before driving up to UC Davis for my externship, I spent a couple weeks studying for the USMLE Step 2 at their house. I'm pretty sure that I wasn't the most pleasant person to be around during those two weeks, but they put up with me anyways, and they did so much to help me get through all the studying.

They set aside a designated study area and respected my need for a quiet study environment. My dad found an empty room at his office that served as an alternate place to study when I got tired of studying at home. My mom was home most of the time, and we chatted or played a quick game of Parcheesi in between question sets or when I needed a short break. We went to the movies together and played pool together in the evenings when it was time to relax. Plus, my mom fed me! Except for all the studying, I had a wonderful time visiting with my parents.

They have already done so much to support me in medical school, and I want them (and everyone else, apparently) to know how much I appreciate everything they do to help me.

In short, my parents are wonderful. Thanks, Mom and Dad!

Friday, August 24, 2012

Escape

After taking the MCAT, I escaped to China. After taking the USMLE Step 1, I escaped to the Utah National Parks. Now that I just finished taking the USMLE Step 2, both Clinical Knowledge and Clinical Skills, I am escaping up the California coast. I love California!


Monday, July 30, 2012

Half-mast

I'm on campus today studying for Step 2, the first time I've been on campus since the Aurora shooting 10 days ago. It was a bit of a shock to me seeing the heightened security and having to show my ID badge to get into the building in which I took all my classes during the first two years of medical school.

I set up shop in a corner room on the second floor, quiet with lots of natural light. It also has a view of the main flagpole standing over the main entrance to campus. The flag was still at half-mast when I arrived this morning, but sometime during my first or second problem sets, the flag was raised back to the top. A sign of this community trying to move on.

Tuesday, July 24, 2012

Oral presentation without notes

Today I had to present a new patient from memory. The team split up in the morning, half going to clinic and the other half rounding quickly on patients. I only had two patients to present, one of which was a new patient I had seen yesterday with an intern and still needed to be staffed with the attending. I realized after it was too late that my intern had taken the History & Physical with her to clinic.

Given my previous struggles with oral presentations, I was a little worried about how this presenting-without-notes thing would play out. To my surprise, though, I not only pulled it off but gave a thorough, concise, and conversational presentation (in my humble opinion). What's more is that the senior attending from another team happened to be at the patient's room and stayed specifically to listen to my presentation, so I had an audience.

It felt good to get it right.

Numerous attendings have told me that the best way to improve my oral presentation is to present without notes. That seemed like an impossible task a few years ago but within reach now that I have some more clinical experience under my belt. I'm going to take their advice now and try to present patients with as little help from notes as possible.

Tuesday, July 10, 2012

Immature

My neurology attending is a big kid dressed up in a suit and tie and a white coat. Don't let the gray hair fool you.

There's a line of tape on the ground in clinic, to help evaluate gait in patients. Today he jumped on the line, arms spread wide, walking it like a tightrope with an exaggerated wobble. Then he banked hard to the left around a corner, made an engine revving sound, and yelled "Airplane turn!"

He turned around and flashed a grin. "You're never too old to be immature!"

I can't wait until I'm established enough to get away with letting out my inner kid like that.

Saturday, June 30, 2012

Smart choice

Earlier this week, I forgot my bike helmet when I left the hospital. There I stood outside the hospital, looking at my bike, trying to decide whether I should go back upstairs to get my helmet or just bike home without it. I was tired and really, really wanted to just go home. But I turned around and went upstairs to get my helmet.

On the elevator ride back down, the elevator stopped at the surgery floor. A man about my age limped inside the elevator. He had a black eye, his mouth was swollen on one side, and he was leaning on a single crutch. He looked down at my helmet and said, "Smart choice. A car hit me a month ago. They had to take out two feet of my small intestine, and I banged my head pretty good."

"Were you wearing a helmet?" I asked, a stupid question because I already knew the answer.

"No."

The elevator doors opened to the ground floor. I thanked the man for sharing with me and wished him a speedy recovery. Then I walked away on two good legs, carrying an atraumatic head on my shoulders, thankful that I decided to go back upstairs for my helmet.


Sunday, June 3, 2012

Medicine sub-internship at Denver Health

I start my Internal Medicine sub-internship tomorrow morning. I decided to do my medicine sub-internship at Denver Health for two main reasons:

First, as a county hospital, Denver Health is the safety net for disadvantaged people who have slipped through the cracks of our broken healthcare system. Such a patient population almost by definition includes a high proportion of people with drug addictions, cognitive impairment, psychotic illnesses, and many other psychiatric comorbidities.

Second, since I also completed my psychiatry sub-internship at Denver Health, this will allow me to more directly compare my psychiatry and medicine sub-internship experiences. Will I enjoy this medicine sub-internship as much as I enjoyed psychiatry? How will this medicine sub-internship influence my feelings about applying to combined medicine/psychiatry residency programs?

While I expect that my plans won't change much as a result of my medicine sub-internship, the possibility remains that two months of back-to-back psychiatry and medicine may clarify which field I'm more passionate about.

Sunday, May 6, 2012

Taking stock of year three: Advice for rising third-years

"The transition from classroom learning to the the clinical years will be the most difficult transition of your careers."

So said one lecturer preparing my class for clinical rotations, one year ago. This sentiment has been echoed by numerous other doctors over the past year. The transition from classroom to clinic represents a fundamental shift in the way that learning takes place, not to mention the additional considerations of teamwork and professionalism. Other major transitions in the medical career (e.g. graduating medical school and becoming an intern, or finishing residency and becoming an attending physician) represent increased responsibility, which is arguably more easy to deal with than a fundamental shift in the way one thinks.

Because of this, I decided that now would be an ideal time to step back, think about all that I have learned over the past year, and pass some of those lessons on to those who will follow me. Keep in mind that that what follows are my own opinions drawn from my own experiences. Other people will have different opinions, and I don't pretend to have all the answers.

1. Attitude. This can be said about anything in life, but I think it's especially true during third-year: A good attitude goes a long way. You are transitioning from learning in a classroom setting to learning in a clinical setting. You will have to figure out how to function well as part of the healthcare team. The reality is that there are many factors outside of your control that will cause you to be a burden on the team. This is more true at the beginning of third year than at the end. Try to minimize your burden on the team, and the best way to do that is to have a good attitude.
  • Be happy; if you're not happy, don't show it.
  • Be easy and fun to work with, even if you don't like your resident or attending.
  • Be excited to learn, even when you're exhausted.
  • Take the initiative when caring for patients.
  • Take as much responsibility as your resident is willing to give you, even if you feel it's a stretch. If a question starts out with "Do you want to..." then the answer is always "Yes."
2. Perspective. Approach every clerkship as if that will be your specialty for the rest of your career. This may sound silly, or impossible, if you know 100% that you do not want to go into that specialty. But I found that this helped me to maintain a good attitude when I very well could have done otherwise. It's a lot easier to work hard if you feel that what you're doing is important. For that matter, if you absolutely hate a clerkship, remember that it will be over in just a few weeks; just push through it.

3. Study. Treat all of third-year as one long study period for Step 2 Clinical Knowledge. In my opinion, every shelf exam that I took was harder than Step 1. For each shelf exam, start studying early and study frequently, a little bit every day. My general approach to studying:
  • Learn from patients. Your patients are your best teachers. Read about your patient's disease on UpToDate: review its pathophysiology, learn different ways that it presents clinically, know its diagnostic criteria and how to treat it. Do a pubmed literature search, if there are any questions related to your patient that can be answered by evidence-based medicine. Then bring back to the team what you find. Information sticks way better when you associate it with one of your patients.
  • Pre-Test. This is a specialty-specific series that offers about 500 questions meant to prepare for shelf exams. I only used the surgery, psychiatry, pediatrics, and Ob/Gyn versions. They are all available as real books or as apps on iTunes. I borrowed the book versions of pre-test for psychiatry and pediatrics but decided to splurge for the $30 iTunes apps for surgery and Ob/Gyn. I'm glad I did, too, because there is a lot of waiting around during those two clerkships, so I would just crank out 5-10 questions whenever I had some time to burn. I finished all 500 questions before each respective test. It's important to note that these questions aren't nearly at the level of difficulty as questions on the real exam. In retrospect, I think pre-test would have been helpful for my family medicine departmental exam. I would stay away from pre-test for Internal Medicine, though, because there's MKSAP, a question bank published by the American College of Physicians. 
  • Step 2 CK question bank. I bought a year-long subscription to Kaplan's Step 2 CK question bank at the beginning of my surgery clerkship and immediately wished that I had gotten it earlier in third year. I'm told that, like Step 1, Kaplan's Step 2 questions are a little harder than what is on the real test. They worked well for me as a shelf exam study aide. Throughout the clerkship, up until the last week, I did just 5-10 questions every other day or so. Then during the last week I did timed full blocks of 44 questions until I ran out of questions, of course reviewing explanations for every question. If I had extra time, I re-answered questions that I got wrong.
  • Specialty-specific textbook. Most clerkships recommended specific text books. The family medicine departmental exam was drawn heavily from Essentials of Family Medicine, which unfortunately is an awful textbook (poorly written, poorly edited, too much emphasis on arcane statistics rather than big picture). The Internal medicine text is Internal Medicine Essentials for Clerkship Students 2 versus Step-Up to Medicine. I chose the first option because it is published by the ACP and is linked to the MKSAP question bank, which I also bought. The surgery departmental exam was drawn heavily from Essentials of General Surgery, which is actually a very well-written book, albeit heavy on text. Ob/Gyn recommended Beckman's Obstetrics and Gynecology, which provided a decent start to studying for the shelf exam. The rest of my clerkships did not recommend any specific textbook.
  • Case Files. This is a specialty-specific series that offers case studies as a means of learning the materials. A patient's case is presented, then questions such as the most likely diagnosis or the diagnostic tests to establish the diagnosis or the means of treatment are asked. A short discussion then expands on those learning points. Each chapter is accompanied by a few softball questions that I found relatively useless. The major utility of Case Files, in my opinion, was talking over the cases with classmates. I only used Case Files for neurology and psychiatry, clerkships without a recommended textbook.
4. Practice. Your jobs as a third-year medical student are to learn how to take a good history, do a good physical exam, and present your findings both in notes and oral presentations. This is all easier said than done. If you're on your first clerkship and you think you're good, you're most likely overestimating yourself. Remember that there is always room for improvement. Don't worry if you're slow and clumsy at first; your residents and attendings expect that at the beginning of your third year, but they also expect steady improvement as you move through the year.
  • Be methodical about how you collect your patient's history. The conventional order is 1) chief complaint, 2) past medical history, 3) past surgical history, 4) medications, 5) allergies, 6) family history, 7) social history. This will quickly be burned into your mind so deeply that it becomes the way you talk about patients in normal conversation. If it helps, create a template for you to fill in as you're interviewing your patient.
  • Sit down when you're talking with patients, even if it means excusing yourself to get a chair or stool. It sets the patient at ease and gives them the impression that you're spending way more time with them than you actually do.
  • Figure out how to end patient interviews without being rude or awkward. This is especially important because you'll often be pressed for time.
  • Try to do a full physical examination, even if it means coming back to see the patient later when you have more time. Obviously this is not always practical, especially in the clinic where an entire patient visit is only 15-20 minutes. But the more normal exam findings you see, the easier it becomes to recognize an abnormal finding.
  • Be proactive about seeing abnormal exam findings, even if it's not on one of your patients.
  • Look to the fourth-year medical student notes as good examples to follow. The attendings and residents typically write more abbreviated and utilitarian notes that are not as useful for learning how to write a good note.
  • Run your assessment and plan by the intern or resident before presenting a patient on rounds, if possible. This is an opportunity to see if he/she agrees with your plan or wants to change anything, and it helps make you look better in front of your attending.
  • Find someone who you can present to as practice, if oral presentations make you nervous. This can be a friend or family member or a significant other. I was fortunate enough to have a resident who taught me how to present, but given how busy residents are, I think this is more the exception than the rule.
  • When presenting, fall back on the methodical approach in which you took the patient's history. This will also save you if you're having a nervous brain-freeze. As you progress, you'll figure out how to pick out pertinent positives and negatives that tell the patient's story and guide the listener to your assessment.
  • Don't forget to present the patient's vital signs!!! Some attendings want to hear each individual vital sign, but most of the time you can summarize it conversationally: "Patient is afebrile, normotensive, normal heart and respiratory rate, and satting well on room air." Or, more succinctly, "Vital signs stable and within normal limits."
5. Relax. No, seriously, relax. This isn't necessarily the most easy thing for me to do, but over the past year I learned how important it is for me to take full advantage of time off, even if that time is just a post-call day. Spend time with family and friends outside of the medical field, or at the very least try not to talk about medicine-related topics when you're hanging out with medical school friends. Think about what hobbies or activities recharge your batteries, and be proactive about scheduling time to do those. Be aggressive about protecting your relaxation time. Otherwise, you will burn out.

Saturday, April 21, 2012

I'm a fourth-year medical student!

As of yesterday at 4pm, when I finished my Ob/Gyn shelf exam, I can officially call myself a fourth-year medical student. Holy cow! Time has passed so quickly with practically every minute of my life accounted for by clinical duties, studying, or scheduled relaxation so I can work and study some more. Also contributing to this feeling of time dilation, the past year has been divided into discrete 2-8 week blocks of intense focus on one subject matter.

This next year promises to fly by even quicker. Sub-internships, externships, USMLE Step 2, residency applications, interviews... and so much more!

Friday, April 13, 2012

Oral presentations: The urge to keep talking

I have made amazing progress in terms of my oral presentations since the beginning of third year. I started out having literally no idea how to properly present a patient. A stellar resident taught me the basics during my Hospitalized Adult Care clerkship, and along the way other residents and attendings interested in teaching have helped to fine-tune my presentation.

Today, I was presenting to my attending an obstetric patient who was in for a regular check-up. The attending remained quiet as I went through all the pertinent subjective information about my patient's pregnancy, described the fetal heart rate and height, and gave her my assessment and plan for this patient.

I was about to talk about the patient's breastfeeding and post-partum birth control plans when my attending said, "Stop!" It's not uncommon for attendings to interrupt oral presentations of medical students. So I stopped, wondering what she was going to say. "Your presentation was perfect. You covered everything I wanted to hear, and you said it succinctly. I know your assessment and plan. You don't need to say anything else. Stop talking!"

The lesson: Part of a good oral presentation is knowing when I've said enough. I should be confident that I have covered all the pertinent details and act on that confidence by ending my presentation. For a third-year medical student who is just now starting to feel comfortable giving oral presentations, this is a valuable lesson to learn.

Sunday, April 8, 2012

Nights on Labor & Delivery

This past week I worked the night shift on Labor & Delivery, from 6pm to 8am. Flip-flopping my schedule like that was disorienting to say the least. While I didn't break down and start a coffee habit, I did eat a fair amount of dark chocolate to keep me alert. In fact, I noticed that eating any food throughout the night helped me stay awake.

When there were things to do, when babies were being born, staying awake was not an issue. Rather, I had difficulty with those long stretches of early-morning quiet. I tried to use the time to study, at first, but my brain wouldn't cooperate. Preparing my progress notes during those quiet hours saved some time in the morning and didn't require too much brain power. If nothing really was happening, and my resident was feeling nice, she would send me to the call room so I could take a 1-2 hour "nap" before rounding on patients at 5am.

Generally, after a night shift, I'd get home at 9am, eat a bowl of cereal, and manage to sleep 3-4 hours in the late-morning and early afternoon. Except one day last week, I had to schedule a bunch of meetings on campus, which meant that I didn't get home until 2pm and was essentially running on no sleep for 2 days straight. I felt miserable.

Looking back, it's a wonder how I functioned at all. A week of nights on Labor & Delivery is as much a medical school hazing ritual as anything. It was definitely the most physically demanding week of medical school I have experienced yet.

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

From clinic to the operating room

A new patient was referred to the gynecology clinic from an outside community clinic that serves a low-income population. She was at the end of her rope dealing with symptoms from a condition that she allowed to progress for so long because she couldn't afford to fix it.

I was working with the chief resident, who is essentially almost a "real" doctor; even she was taken aback. "I'm going to go talk with the supervising doctor, and we'll see what we can do for you." The attending was equally impressed with the patient's history and physical exam and scheduled her for surgery the very next day.

My resident invited me to watch the surgery. "It'll give you a chance to follow a patient from start to finish." Thank you so much! This kind of continuity, as a medical student, is not the norm. I had to play hookie from afternoon clinic (with the chief's permission) in order to see my patient's surgery.

During the first two weeks of this clerkship, I saw many surgeries on women whom I had never met and never examined. The only history I knew of them is what I read in their chart and what the resident told me beforehand. Occasionally, I'd have a few minutes to chat with these patients immediately before surgery. But the whole experience felt disjointed.

That's why I'm incredibly grateful to have experienced the kind of continuity of care, from clinic to surgery, that the residents and attendings enjoy. The attending even stepped back allowing my resident to operate and leaving me to first-assist! And she invited me to accompany her to talk with the patient's family afterward! The experience felt complete.

I think more effort should be made to give medical students this kind of patient continuity. In terms of teaching and learning, I personally find that such continuity is especially effective: I will never forget this patient.

Sunday, March 11, 2012

OB/Gyn prejudices

A friend recently asked me, "Are you looking forward to or dreading your OB/Gyn rotation?" I don't think either term adequately describes how I feel about this clerkship.

OB/Gyn is the one specialty that I pretty much knew 100% I didn't want to go into even before third year. But, I recognize that my OB/Gyn experience will be very educational and an opportunity that I likely won't have during the rest of my career. So I am definitely looking forward to the experience of OB/Gyn, especially the OB part that involves delivering babies. That being said, I'm also looking forward to being done with the clerkship.

Do I dread OB/Gyn? I have to admit that there are certain aspects of OB/Gyn that are slightly anxiety-provoking. I've heard disconcerting stories about some OB/Gyn residents and attendings. I'm wondering how I'll actually be received by patients, as a male medical student. I'll also be straightforward and say that I'm not looking forward to doing pelvic exam after pelvic exam for the next six weeks. But, like everything else in medical school, it's something that I just do, putting in my best effort and with a good attitude, even if I don't want to make a career out of OB/Gyn.

It'll be interesting to see how my opinions of OB/Gyn at the end of the clerkship compare to my prejudices of it now.

Saturday, March 10, 2012

Pushing back against the war on vaccines

It was bound to happen eventually on my pediatrics rotation: coming across parents who for one reason or another refuse to vaccinate their children.

The most recent anti-vaccination movement stems from a 1998 Lancet article that ostensibly showed a link between the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine and a so-called "bowel-brain syndrome" that involves non-specific bowel inflammation and a regressive type of autism. Vaccination opponents seized upon this article as legitimization of their views while the medical community collectively gasped.

Much has been written about the methodological and ethical problems with the study; a lot of time and energy was invested into reproducing or disproving the results of this study. Ultimately, though, it was an investigative journalist who showed that the author of MMR-autism study had allegedly cooked the data for financial gain (How the case against the MMR vaccine was fixed, British Medical Journal, 5 JAN 2011). This led to a formal investigation, public censure of the primary author, and the paper's retraction more than a decade after its publication.

But not before the damage was done. The authors of this paper used a respected and authoritative medical journal as a platform to spread what appear to be lies, the result of which was millions of parents questioning whether they should give their children the MMR vaccine - or any vaccine - for fear that it will cause autism. Many parents who had the misfortune of learning that their child has autism, desperately searching for reason, have stumbled upon the falsehoods spread by this article that seemingly explain the unexplainable.

Vaccinating children: Keeping the dialogue open

This is a dilemma faced by pediatricians worldwide, dealing with parents who are skeptical of vaccines or who flat-out refuse to vaccinate their children.

One such parent stood out over the course of my pediatrics rotation. She is the mother of an autistic child who hadn't received any vaccinations since 18 months and was coming in for a well-child visit. My preceptor warned me that this child's immunizations were not up to date and that the mother would likely continue to refuse all vaccinations. "What's your approach to such a parent?" I asked because some pediatricians (including one provider who I worked with previously) just have the parent sign a form without any discussion. "I always keep the patient in my practice, and I try to keep the dialogue open," she replied.

So, when it came time to talk about immunizations, I jumped right in:
"It seems that he's not up to date on his immunizations. Which shots do you want him to get today?"

Mom replied: "I don't want him to get any shots."

Feigned surprise: "Why not?"

"I just don't. He doesn't need them."

"Why do you think he doesn't need immunizations?"

"He just doesn't. He's not going to get sick."

My preceptor interjected: "Do you think there's a link between vaccinations and your son's autism? The only scientific publication that suggested a link was--"

"No, I don't believe that."

I sat back and thought for a few moments, perhaps slightly theatrically. "Tell me, what's your understanding of the diseases that these vaccinations protect against?" This question seemed to catch Mom off guard. The door was cracked slightly open, so I took the opportunity to educate Mom about hepatitis A and measles and mumps and rubella and chicken pox....

Oops, tactical error. Mom jumped on the chicken pox: "See, why does my son have to get a shot for chicken pox? I had it when I was a kid, and I did just fine!"

My preceptor rescued me: "Before we started vaccinating against chicken pox, a few hundred kids died from it every year. Percentage-wise, that might not sound like a lot, but if it's your kid who doesn't come home from the hospital because of chicken pox, then those chances are 100% for you. Did you have any complications from your chicken pox?"

"Yes, I was hospitalized for two days."

Then my preceptor closed the deal: "Well, it would be a horrible shame if your boy had to go through something like that if he didn't need to."

In the end, Mom agreed to vaccinate her boy against hepatitis A, influenza, and chicken pox, all that same day. She also agreed to vaccinate him against measles, mumps, and rubella, only if we could give those as separate shots.

Done!

I felt a real sense of accomplishment. Partially because of me, this little boy would now be protected against several serious diseases.

My opinion: Why every child should be vaccinated

Vaccines in general arguably represent the single most important development in medicine, ever. Some people may counter that antibiotics are a more significant advancement, and I'll give them that it would be a good debate.

But think for a moment: What would the world be like today if no vaccine had ever been developed? Just for starters, the world would still be ravaged by smallpox, a disease that few people can truly appreciate how devastating it really was. To put this in perspective, the Wikipedia page refers to smallpox in the past tense, citing its eradication in 1979! Then there's polio, which is so very close to also being referred to in the past tense thanks to a coordinated worldwide campaign to eradicate polio. Warehouses full of people living inside iron lungs are a nightmare of the past; we will never again have a President of the United States confined to a wheelchair because of polio.

Measles (one of the M's in MMR) is a great example of a horrific disease that practically disappeared because of population-wide vaccination but has recently made a resurgence, partly owing to the people who were never vaccinated against it. Measles is an incredibly infectious disease, which means that it's very easy to spread from one person to another. That in turn means that eradicating it will be that much more difficult, especially if there are significant pockets of the population who are susceptible to it. Recently, PBS reported on a mini-outbreak of 13 measles cases after the 2012 Super Bowl; all 13 cases had opted out of the MMR vaccine. In developed countries, one person will die of measles for every 1000 people who get the disease; mortality jumps to 5-10% for measles infections in developing countries (PLoS Med. 2007 January; 4(1): e24). Those are odds I wouldn't want to play around with.

The logic is simple: If you're vaccinated against Disease X, then you will not get Disease X. Given that the consequences of getting many of these preventable diseases include permanent disability, or worse, death, it's hard for me to understand why loving parents would would choose to not vaccinate their child.

Thursday, March 8, 2012

A special mentor

The second half of my pediatrics clerkship was much better than the first half. This was partially thanks to working in a practice that focuses on special needs children, an interesting twist to what otherwise would have been three weeks of garden variety ear infections, upper respiratory infections, and stomach aches. But I mainly attribute the quality of my outpatient pediatrics experience to my preceptor. She's a role model for the kind of physician I hope to become, even if I won't be going into pediatrics.

She makes a real difference in her patients' lives; they travel surprising distances just to see her. She is a passionate advocate for her patients' physical and mental health in the context of an often hostile health care system. She is an excellent clinician, able to identify the rarest diseases with simple observations accumulated over her decades-long career. And in her spare time, she has traveled throughout the world participating in medical aid missions. She loves what she does and gains true satisfaction from her work.

I wish I could have spent more time with her.